Role Modeled
I’ve watched “True Blood” from the beginning. I was a fan of the books for years, so for season one, I talked my husband into letting us get HBO just for the duration of the new episodes. When season 2 was on we couldn’t afford it, so I persuaded a friend to let me come over when she was at work and watch the first half of the season on her DVR. I watched the second half while visiting family in New Orleans for the Words and Music Festival. Twenty-six years old, away from husband and baby, in one of the country’s most exciting cities, and I happily sat around catching up on TV. True story.
Anyway, this year we’ve got HBO again, and, especially because it’s summer, “True Blood” is the show I most look forward to each week. I’m actually sad as I watch it, because I know that in just a few weeks it’ll be over for the season, and I’ll have to wait a whole year for new episodes. (Stupid pay cable.) I can tell you that I love “The West Wing” because of Aaron Sorkin’s brilliant writing, or “Chuck” because of the actor who brings such humor and likability to the title role, but I honestly can’t put a finger on exactly why I love True Blood. There’s no one specific reason; it’s just hopelessly entertaining.
Anyway, with the season finale coming up and “True Blood” on the brain, I’ve been re-reading some of the early books, and as I’ve kept going, something has been tugging at my mind, some detail I should be noticing. Today I figured out what it was: this is the first time I’ve read these early books since “Twilight.”
As someone who writes in this genre, I can tell you that the “Twilight” books have become the ultimate elephant in the room. They’re like if the elephant in the room was covered in a sea of blood and being hunted by a jillion teenage girls. For me, trying to write in this genre now means constantly asking myself, “Is this plotline/character/joke/fight scene/backstory too much like something that happened in the Twilight saga?” And if so, engage delete button. I now have a big list of Twilight details taking up valuable real estate in my brain. You know when you’re at the grocery story, and you look in the cart to make sure you have everything on your list? Well, I have to check the cart to make sure NOTHING I have is on the list. It’s incredibly annoying, because this is a genre with a lot of overlap. Everyone has vampires, and werewolves, and until Twilight came around, that was perfectly fine. Everybody did their own thing. Now I can’t get rid of the damned (metaphorical) elephant.
And I’m not the only one. This is still the genre I most love to read, and unfortunately a lot of the more recent urban fantasy novels come with baggage. There’s this sense of I’m trying really hard to make this different from Twlight or Look see this is completely different from Twlight. Maybe this is just paranoia talking, but sometimes I’ll come across some ridiculous detail and suspect that the author only put it in to avoid Twilight comparisons. Their vampires are always bald, or are contagious to howler monkeys or something. Even with the more subdued writers, you can often feel the author tiptoeing around, trying not to call your attention to any similarities. (Which is kind of ridiculous because similarities will be inevitable, if someone is really working to find them. Does your book have vampires? Yup. Will some “Twilight"-obsessed fan probably find a parallel somewhere? Yup again.)
But, I digress. My point is that Sookie Stackhouse was reading minds and being immune to vamp powers a good four years before Edward and Bella made it cool. And because of that, Charlaine Harris’s early books (we won’t talk about the downhill slide of the last two or three) have a relaxed, folksy sense of fun that is missing from any of the post-Twilight urban fantasies I’ve read. It makes me long to be a writer ten years ago, instead of now. Will I ever be able to write in this genre with that kind of freedom? Will I always be tiptoeing around the damned elephant?
Maybe. But at least Harris gives me something to aspire to.